It actually wasn’t all that dangerous.
That, a minimum of, was the consensus response from a dozen historians to whom Politicoposed a query within the waning hours of the previous yr: “Was 2017 the Craziest Yr in U.S. Political Historical past?”
Just one answered within the affirmative. The remaining deferred to years they contemplate crazier, together with 1861, the yr America went to conflict with itself over slavery, 1919, the yr of the “Purple Summer time” race riots and 1968, the yr of the Democratic conference riots, the MLK and RFK assassinations and the Tet offensive. One historian, H.W. Manufacturers of the College of Texas, stated that, in comparison with the primary years of the Lincoln, Franklin Roosevelt, and each Bush presidencies, our first yr underneath Trump was “a yawner.”
Granted, the query they have been requested was so obscure — how are we defining “loopy,” in any case? — as to be in some sense unanswerable. And it is true sufficient that 2017 noticed no main transformative or disruptive occasions on the size of 1861 and even 1968.
Nonetheless, I might argue that in primarily writing it off as a so-referred to as “yawner,” the panel underestimates 2017. One thing did occur final yr. It was straightforward to overlook as a result of it was not stark or spectacular — no riot, conflict or secession. No, this was delicate and insidious, however all of the extra foreboding for that.
2017, you see, was the yr the final norms fell. These norms, i.e., our sense of what’s allowable and acceptable on the general public stage, have been eroding for years, however 2017 noticed the method speed up like Usain Bolt. It was the yr issues that aren’t purported to occur occurred all day, each day.
A president simply does not ridicule his personal FBI and CIA. Or intrude with unbiased investigations. Or bully the free press. Or converse kindly of white supremacists and credibly accused baby molesters. Or use his workplace for private achieve when everybody can see him doing it or lie when even infants know he is mendacity. He does not threaten nuclear warfare by way of Twitter.
A president merely does not do these issues. Besides that now, evidently, he does. And that is scary.
Politics — and civil society as an entire — rests on a basis of largely unstated agreements, a social covenant that defines us in relation to at least one one other, units forth the duties we owe and the expectations we keep in deference to the bigger us. There have all the time been issues our leaders…