Frat members seek dismissal in Penn State pledge death case


By MARK SCOLFORO
Related Press

BELLEFONTE, Pa. (AP) – Legal professionals for members of a now-closed Penn State fraternity requested a district decide Wednesday to dismiss some or all the costs associated to a pledge’s demise, arguing their shoppers did not act recklessly or maliciously throughout an evening of consuming and hazing.

The sixth day of a preliminary listening to wrapped up with attorneys for eleven of the 17 defendants nonetheless ready to make last arguments earlier than a decide will determine whether or not to ship fees to county courtroom for trial.

Legal professionals for the 5 frat brothers who face probably the most critical offenses, together with involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault, attacked the prosecution’s case in hopes District Decide Allen Sinclair will at the least pare down the a whole lot of fees they collectively face.

The lawyer for Brendan Younger, who was chapter president the night time in February that 19-yr-previous Tim Piazza drank a harmful quantity and fell a number of occasions, argued Younger noticed nothing to make him assume the pledge was liable to dying.

“He wasn’t there by means of the entire night time. He didn’t observe any accidents to Mr. Piazza. He didn’t observe something that might lead him to consider that he was at substantial danger,” Younger’s lawyer, Frank Fina, informed Sinclair.

Fina stated Younger’s complete publicity to Piazza’s consuming lasted solely 12 seconds, and there are unanswered questions on how a lot Piazza drank and the way he obtained it.

“We will not say at what level his tragic accidents have been deadly that night time,” Fina argued. “And we will not determine all the intervening occasions and the unknowns that contributed and even triggered a few of Mr. Piazza’s accidents.”

Centre County District Lawyer Stacy Parks Miller stated Younger was “answerable for the fraternity” and despatched textual content messages afterward indicating he was accountable.

She stated the defendants led Piazza to hazing and extreme velocity consuming, aiming to see “how drunk they might get him within the shortest interval attainable.”

That conduct, she argued, meets state requirements for legal legal responsibility.

“They knew that dying was a probably critical consequence,” Parks Miller stated. “They proceeded within the face of it anyhow. That’s recklessness.”

Andy Shubin was among the many legal professionals objecting to Parks Miller’s references to the defendants as a gaggle. Eight face involuntary…



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *